Home server or VPS?

If you want to self-host apps, you have two main places to run them: a computer at home, such as an old PC, a mini PC or a Raspberry Pi, or a VPS in a data centre. Both work. They differ in cost, reliability, internet speed, storage and how easy they are to reach from outside.

This guide compares them honestly, shows how to work out what a home server really costs to run, and explains the setup many people end up with: a home server for big storage, and a small VPS as its secure front door.

Small VPS plans in stock, often enough as a front door for a home server

In stock when this page loaded. See all 7 matching plans

What is in this guide

A few words you will see

TermWhat it means
Home serverA computer at home that runs all the time to host apps or files.
Upload speedHow fast your home connection sends data out. Often much slower than download speed.
Public IP addressAn address the internet can reach directly. Many homes do not have one of their own.
CGNATWhen your ISP shares one public address between many homes, so you cannot open ports.
Port forwardingA router setting that sends outside connections to a computer at home.
UptimeThe share of time a server is running and reachable.
kWhKilowatt-hour: the unit your electricity is billed in.

Side by side

Home serverVPS
Upfront costThe hardware, unless you reuse an old machineNone
Running costElectricity, plus hardware replacement over timeThe plan's price
StorageLarge disks are cheap to addLimited by the plan
PowerCan be strong, including a graphics cardSet by the plan
Internet speed outLimited by your home upload speedData centre connection, usually fast both ways
Reachable from outsideSometimes hard, depending on your ISPYes, with its own public IP address
ReliabilityDepends on your power, internet and hardwareData centre power and network
Physical controlThe machine and disks are in your handsThe hardware is the provider's
Noise, heat and spaceYours to live withNot your problem
Access to home devicesYes, on the same networkOnly through a VPN link to home

Where a home server wins

  • Lots of storage. Media libraries, photo archives and backups of large amounts of data are far cheaper on your own disks.
  • Heavy computing. A home machine with a graphics card can run larger AI models or convert video quickly, which most VPS plans cannot.
  • Home automation. Smart home software needs to talk to devices on your home network.
  • Fast access at home. Files and media load at your local network's speed.
  • Physical privacy. Your data never leaves your house.

Where a VPS wins

  • Anything public. Websites, shared services and anything other people use need good upload speed and steady uptime.
  • Reachability. A VPS has its own public IP address. Many home connections do not, or change it often.
  • Reliability. Power cuts, broadband outages and someone unplugging the wrong thing do not take a VPS down.
  • Off-site copies. A backup on a VPS survives a fire, flood or burglary at home.
  • No hardware to maintain, no noise and no heat.
  • Your home stays private. Visitors to a site on a VPS never connect to your home address.

Working out the real cost of a home server

A home server is not free just because you already own it. Electricity is the main running cost. The sum is:

Watts used, times 24 hours, times 365 days, divided by 1,000, gives kWh per year. Multiply by your price per kWh.

Here is an illustrative example with made-up figures. A small PC using 30 watts on average uses 30 x 24 x 365 divided by 1,000, which is about 263 kWh a year. At an example price of 0.30 per kWh in your currency, that is about 79 a year. An old desktop using 80 watts would use about 700 kWh, or about 210 a year at the same example price.

Use your own machine's real power use, which a cheap plug-in power meter can measure, and your own electricity price. Then add:

  • Replacement disks and parts over the years.
  • Any backup storage off-site, which you need anyway.
  • Your time to maintain the hardware as well as the software.

Compare the total with VPS plans of the size you need, in the live lists on this page. For small jobs, a VPS is often cheaper than leaving a power-hungry old PC running. For large storage, a home server usually wins.

Reaching a home server from outside

To use a home server away from home, it needs to be reachable. Your options depend on your ISP:

SituationOptionNotes
You have a public IP addressPort forwarding on your routerExposes your home network directly. Keep it to a VPN port only, never admin panels
Your ISP uses CGNAT, or you would rather not open portsA VPN link from home to a VPSThe home server connects out to the VPS, so no ports open at home
Only you need accessA VPN on the VPS, with your devices and home server as peersThe safest choice for private apps

The VPS route works on almost any home connection and keeps your home address private. Setting up a WireGuard VPN on a VPS covers the VPN. Add the home server as another peer, just like a phone or laptop.

Check your ISP's terms too. Some home broadband plans do not allow running public servers.

2 GB VPS plans in stock, for a VPN plus a few public apps

In stock when this page loaded. See every plan

Which job goes where

JobUsually best onWhy
Public website or blogVPSUptime and upload speed
Password managerVPS, reached through a VPNAlways reachable, off-site
Uptime monitoringVPSShould not depend on the home connection it watches
Off-site backupsVPSSurvives problems at home
Media libraryHomeBig storage and fast local playback
Photo archiveHome, with an off-site backupStorage cost
Home automationHomeNeeds local devices
Larger AI modelsHome with a graphics card, or a dedicated serverNeeds more power than most VPS plans
Game server for friendsVPSFair speed for everyone, no home address shared

Self-hosted apps you can run on a VPS lists what each app needs.

Using both together

Many self-hosters settle on a mix:

  1. A home server for bulky storage, media and anything that needs local devices or a graphics card.
  2. A small VPS running a WireGuard VPN, which the home server and your devices all connect to.
  3. Public sites and always-on services on the VPS, where uptime and upload speed are better.
  4. Backups of the home server's important files sent to the VPS or another off-site place, and the other way round.

That way each part does what it is best at, and neither your home address nor your private apps are exposed to the internet.

Limits

  • Home connections vary. Upload speed, public IP addresses and ISP rules differ between providers and plans. Check yours.
  • Electricity figures here are examples. Measure your own.
  • A VPS has fair-use limits. Unmetered does not mean unlimited. Streaming a large media library from a VPS uses lots of bandwidth, and RackNerd's acceptable use policy applies.
  • Both need security. A home server exposed through port forwarding can put your whole home network at risk. See securing your VPS, which applies at home too.
  • Hardware fails. A home server has no spare parts on standby. Plan for a disk dying.

When to step up

If your VPS is only a VPN front door, the smallest plan is usually enough. Step up when you move apps from home to the VPS, or run public services there. For heavy storage or computing that you would rather not keep at home, a dedicated server sits between the two: big disks and power, in a data centre.

Dedicated servers in stock with the most disk, an alternative to a home server

In stock when this page loaded. See all 71 matching plans

To compare what is available now, start with the cheapest RackNerd VPS guide and check the sales page.

More RackNerd guides